The Australian government has taken notice of concerns exposed by an inquiry into international education in the country, revealing alarming instances of overseas students being exploited by education agents who entice them to switch universities and colleges. These agents stand accused of prioritizing personal financial gains at the expense of students’ welfare, prompting urgent calls for enhanced industry regulation. While opinions diverge on whether to focus primarily on onshore agents within Australia or to implement comprehensive oversight across the entire international education sector, the need for stronger measures to combat exploitation, particularly the poaching of existing international students, remains a pressing concern.
To address this issue, the Australian Education Minister, Jason Clare, has taken a firm stance by introducing a series of reforms aimed at curbing the exploitation of international students and the unethical practice of poaching from universities and colleges by certain educational institutions. These reforms include the prohibition of colleges paying commissions to agents involved in such activities. In addition to this, the government is set to implement measures like monitoring student attendance, implementing a “fit and proper person” assessment for college owners, and prohibiting cross-ownership between colleges and education agents to combat exploitative and criminal practices. Minister Clare emphasized the necessity of these reforms to counter the resurgence of unscrupulous operators seeking to undermine the integrity of Australia’s international education system. These changes come in response to the rising number of student visa holders and reports of widespread abuse within the visa system, particularly concerning Indian students who exploit loopholes to switch from established universities to more affordable private colleges, resulting in universities witnessing a significant influx of students who either never attend or abandon their courses.
Why Students and Agents Engage in Malpractice in the Education System
-
Financial Incentives:
Education agents receive commissions for poaching students from one institution to another, creating a financial incentive for both agents and students to engage in this malpractice.
-
Cost Considerations:
International students, particularly those from India, exploit loopholes in the system to abandon expensive courses at established universities in favor of more affordable private colleges, driven by financial considerations.
-
Job Market Entry:
Some students use student visas as a means to access the job market, with certain colleges acting as mere fronts, lacking teaching and administrative facilities, which enables this exploitation.
-
Generous Discounts:
Colleges and universities offer generous discounts to attract students to switch institutions, further fueling the practice of poaching.
Proposed Solution
To address the pervasive issues within the education system, the Australian government is proposing a multifaceted solution. The introduction of stricter monitoring of student attendance aims to curb the misuse of student visas as a means to access the job market, especially in colleges with inadequate teaching and administrative facilities. The government plans to crack down on education agents who engage in student poaching for financial gain, as well as colleges and universities that offer lucrative discounts to lure students away from their current institutions. Additionally, the government is bolstering the authority of education regulators to oversee these changes. However, concerns remain about the effectiveness of these measures, particularly in light of previous unsuccessful reforms and the need for more objective pass/fail measures to complement risk indicators. Moreover, the proposed reforms are not limited to students alone but also target bogus asylum seekers, who often overlap with those engaged in malpractice within the education system. Further reforms are expected to be announced in the near future by Skills Minister Brendan O’Connor, reflecting the government’s commitment to addressing these challenges comprehensively.
